SoFi Technologies (SOFI) Stock Falls 41% YTD — Is the Selloff Overdone?

TLDR

• SOFI is down roughly 1% on the day and has fallen 41% year-to-date, though it has gained 70% over the past year.
• The recent pullback comes as investors question whether the stock got overbought after rallying on hopes around its Big Business Banking platform and crypto services push.
• SoFi posted a strong Q4 2025 — EPS of $0.13 (beating estimates by 8.3%) and revenue topping $1 billion for the first time, up 40% year-over-year.
• Valuation concerns are mounting: the stock trades at a P/E of 42.68x, well above the industry average of 8.27x, and one model pegs fair value at around $12.49 — implying 29% overvaluation.
• Key risks include heavy reliance on personal loans (nearly 70% of its portfolio), a weak current ratio of 0.78, and no dividend.

SoFi Technologies has had a wild ride. After a sharp rally driven by optimism around its expanding digital finance ecosystem, the stock is now pulling back as enthusiasm cools. The day’s move is modest — down around 1% — but zooming out tells a starker story: SOFI is off 41% in 2025 so far.

SoFi Technologies, Inc., SOFI

The $16.11 price sits well above what at least one valuation model considers fair. Using an excess returns framework, analysts estimate intrinsic value at around $12.49 per share — putting the stock about 29% above that mark. Its P/E of 42.68x is more than five times the consumer finance industry average of 8.27x.

That said, the underlying business has been delivering. In Q4 2025, SoFi crossed the $1 billion revenue threshold for the first time and grew net sales 40% year-over-year. EPS came in at $0.13, beating consensus estimates by 8.3% and marking a 160% improvement. CEO Anthony Noto’s insider buying earlier in the year also gave some investors confidence — before sentiment started to shift.

What’s Driving the Business

The Galileo technology platform is one of the more interesting pieces of the SoFi story. Other financial firms are increasingly licensing it, which could turn SoFi into a fintech infrastructure provider — not just a consumer lender. Smaller banks, in particular, may find it cheaper to license Galileo than to build their own digital systems.

Rate cuts have also been helpful. The Fed’s easing cycle, which ran through 2025 and is expected to continue into 2026, has lowered borrowing costs and pushed more consumers toward new loans or refinancing. For a lending-heavy fintech, that’s a useful macro tailwind.

A $2 billion partnership with Fortress Investment Group is intended to shift more revenue toward fee-based models — less capital-intensive, more predictable. New credit card launches and the Nova Credit integration for risk assessment are also part of a broader push to deepen its member base.

Where the Risk Lives

Nearly 70% of SoFi’s lending portfolio is in personal loans — unsecured debt that carries higher default risk than most other loan types. If delinquency rates rise, margins could come under real pressure.

Liquidity is another concern. As of December 31, 2025, SoFi’s current ratio stood at 0.78, below the industry average of 1.2. A ratio under 1 means short-term liabilities exceed short-term assets. The company also pays no dividend, so investors are entirely reliant on price appreciation.

Analysts currently rate SOFI a Hold (Zacks Rank #3). Bullish scenarios put fair value as high as $38, while more cautious models sit around $12.37. The current price of $16.11 lands between those two views, closer to the bearish end.

The post SoFi Technologies (SOFI) Stock Falls 41% YTD — Is the Selloff Overdone? appeared first on CoinCentral.